It’s time to take a collective deep breath. The recent election in the US – and all that led up to it – has stirred up so much emotion in us, regardless of what side “of the aisle” we’re on. Depending on your point of view you may be feeling elated and hopeful or sad and fearful – and many emotions in between. Much has been said about the extreme polarization that has become our “new normal” in this country – why it has become this way, the impact of social media, the selective consumption of news, the perceived relativity of what is “fact” vs. our interpretation…
And it certainly doesn’t take an expert in social science to see that this dynamic and other forces at play have caused strife — even anger and contempt – between us individually in our relationships as well as between and among groups of people who see things differently.
Sometimes I feel deeply discouraged by this state of affairs we are in. It can feel so overwhelming – how does this dynamic change? It feels so big, so deep-seated – where would we even START to begin to change this painful state of polarization? It feels so vast, so complex, so entrenched. How could a “little person like me” ever begin to create an impact?
The good news is, that is exactly where this change begins – with ME. And with YOU. And with every one of us who has the courage and the heart to begin to step up differently, listen more deeply, and open our hearts to seeing the pain and fear, the deepest motivations of others. I’m not saying this is easy – it involves taking a risk, putting ourselves out there, and putting aside our temptation to KNOW and the need to BE RIGHT. It begins with a choice – making a decision to override our “autopilot” tendency to judge and then feeling the all-too-familiar feelings of justification in service of stepping into greater empathy, compassion, and gentleness. This is deeply personal work – the practice of noticing what is arising within ourselves, and then consciously, intentionally making a shift toward a new mindset, a different set of behaviors.
We can begin right here, as one “little person” to do our part in making this collective shift of consciousness.
Here are a few ways to start:
- Take a deep breath. Again. And Again. Brain physiology shows that deep breathing helps produce relaxation in the body. A more relaxed presence is a precursor to having more open conversations and to engage in what could be more difficult interactions that challenge our world views. Breathing helps keep us calmer and more centered. I think we can agree that people who are blaming and angrily spewing a point of view are probably not calm and centered while engaging in that way. Staying calm and centered is a critical first step to having better conversations.
- Assume Positive Intent. It has been said that we see what we look for. When we move through the world from a mindset that other people are somehow defective, evil-intending, or out to get us – the conspiracy theory mindset – we are making impossible the act of coming together. We get more of the behavior that then “validates” our world view. When we assume the other person is doing the best they can do and are coming from a positive intention, it shifts the whole field. This makes greater understanding possible. Note that we don’t have to necessarily agree with their point of view to be able to engage and learn. But we can look for what is good in them and recognize that, like all of us, this person is experiencing their own struggles that have led them to where they are today.
- Listen for motivation and what’s important. Often what gets lost in the “noise” of advocacy of this policy or that policy or stance is what is most important to me about that. When we can peel back the layers of the onion by asking “what’s most important to you about that,” we often are able to tap into a human need that we actually can understand and respect (even if we may not agree with the policy). This enables us to engage with each other as human beings – not as mouthpieces for the “left” or “right” — and to create the possibility for greater understanding and common ground.
- Imagine the pain or fear that may be underlying the passion. Closely related to #3, embracing my full humanity means tapping into my empathy for the other person – trying to imagine the world from their experience. What is the pain or fear they are trying to avoid by adopting their view? Most extreme views or advocacy have at their root an abiding fear of something. Sometimes acknowledging the person’s fear can go a long way toward calming them, helping them feel “seen,” and enabling a more productive conversation by breaking through some of the “armoring” (as put so well by Brene Brown) we put up to protect ourselves.
- Recognize the Polarities that Exist. So many of our conversations or interactions get stalled by “either/or thinking” – the false choices that pit us against one another. When we replace this with BOTH / AND thinking, we are solution oriented and more apt to address root causes and new possibilities to unite. For example, it is possible to both support social justice/ reforms AND support the police. It is possible to want climate change policy reforms AND want to create a thriving business community / economy. These are called polarities – two conditions that both exist simultaneously. To manage polarities, we work to create the “up sides” of each pole, while avoiding the down sides of each. Often, I notice people talking past each other by getting stuck in limiting either/or thinking and false choices that are neither necessary nor helpful. Search for the polarities that may exist and new possibilities bloom.
- Seek out areas of commonality. When we engage in #2-5, we are well on our way to being able to “mine” for what we have in common. Let’s see, how can we ensure a thriving business environment and economic benefits while protecting the earth? What about what we’ve just discussed seems important to each of us? That’s a starting point for productive conversation – and coming together.
- Be willing to be Vulnerable. This one may be most challenging, in many ways – and yet so critical. Lack of vulnerability is evidenced in the “armor” we wear: it may show up as a chip on our shoulder, an unwillingness to admit a mistake or not knowing something, an unwillingness to let our full humanity be shown. This prevents intimacy and trust building and hinders real conversations. Being a force for healing requires us to really be human – to show up as the perfectly imperfect being that we are. When we can admit that we don’t know something, admit a mistake or misstep, apologize from the heart (note: a wholehearted, healing apology is not “I’m sorry that you were mad when I ____ because of ____”), we create an opening for true understanding – and healing. If we are going to be a force for healing and unity, we must be willing to put ourselves out there and be real – otherwise, we are condoning the game-playing that is a barrier to breaking down the walls that keep us in our ideological corners.
- Make Gentleness your Home Base. One of the enduring legacies that my father, now deceased, left with me and my sisters was the gentle, kind spirit that was part of his overall presence. As anyone knew him could attest, he was a man of very strong political beliefs and great passion about justice and fairness and he could argue his beliefs with the precision and logic that made it difficult for even the most confident debaters to prevail. Yet he did so from a deeply embodied place of kindness, respect, and a gentle spirit that made his arguments not personal or attacking. At the end of the day, he still loved that friend or family member deeply and his gentleness was the prevailing energy that remained after their “debate.” I try to adopt that – and fail often – but it is my guiding beacon.“Did I treat that person kindly and gently?”
- Diminishing the polarization – with its angry mindsets and vitriole that makes true dialogue all but impossible – requires each one of us to do our part, in our own relationships and our own human ecosystem (and in our social media too!), to bring a sense of gentleness and healing. “Many hands make light work.” It starts with me. And since I am the only one who can choose how I will show up, I’m not powerless over this dynamic, but instead wonderfully empowered to be the change I want to see in the world. Good news for this wobbly time.